Sunday, February 7, 2016
The Whites of Their Lies
BC's lobby laws in
need of makeover
Travis, Integrity BC
month, lobbyists gathered in Vancouver for The Future of Lobbying, a one
-day conference put on by B.C.'s Office of the Registrar of Lobbyists,
Simon Fraser Institute's Governance Studies and Public Affairs
Association of Canada (B.C. Chapter).
Hate to be the bearer of bad news, but there does seem to be a future
for the industry. In fact, if we're not careful, B.C. could be
overrun by lobbyists.
Last year, there were 2,502 in-house and consultant lobbyists registered
in the province, up from 1,451 four years ago. Whoever said the B.C.
Jobs Plan wasn't working?
While others do get some attention – political staff, deputy ministers
and the like – that works out to 30 lobbyists for every MLA.
In Ottawa, there are 3,008 lobbyists or nine per MP.
As one of 14 panelists at the Vancouver conference, it fell on me to
provide a bit of insight on the public's perspective towards the
industry and a few ideas on how it might be improved.
Somehow has to rain on the parade of rainmakers. Not a tough task,
though. There's no shortage of material.
Last month, Missouri state legislator, Bart Korman, tabled Bill 2059.
If it becomes law, lobbyists in that state would be required to disclose
any sex given by a lobbyist to a lawmaker or their staff each month. A
dollar valuation will not be required when reporting sexual acts. Be
thankful for small mercies.
Closer to home, former B.C. lobbyist Marcella Munro found herself in a
pickle after taking a post with Alberta's new NDP government.
The Wildrose party was only too happy to blast her appointment by
pointing to some of Munro's B.C. blog posts, including: “that saying no
to projects like Kinder Morgan, to protect our environment and quality
of life” are things to be celebrated.
The posts were quickly taken down and replaced with Alberta-centric
“My BMW 325i is my favourite possession” was Munro's new riff, telling
the Calgary Herald: “there's no planet on which I could try to
argue against the oilsands. I love all the good things petroleum does
for me — including driving too fast on Highway 2.”
As the Herald's Don Braid put it: “If you have trouble reconciling the
contradictions, you are most likely a regular human unconnected with the
murky, interlinked worlds of lobbying, campaigning and government
If the industry is an unavoidable evil of modern politics, it was then
sacrilege time for the assembled.
First up: transparency.
Reporting only intent to lobby – as the legislation currently requires –
isn't good enough. The “if I'm really, really lucky the minister might
open my email before he triple deletes it,” isn't the best approach for
reporting lobbying activities.
It's meetings that count and lobbyists should be required to report who
they've met with as well.
Those on the other end of the bargain – MLAs, political staff, deputy
ministers – should also disclose who is lobbying them.
Good way to check to see if everyone's reporting matches up.
Fees paid by clients should be disclosed, as is done in the United
Last year, 11,169 lobbyists working Washington, D.C. billed US$2.4
billion, an average of $215,000 each.
A province-wide registry for municipal lobbyists is long over due.
Contingency fee agreements need to be trashed, as is the case at the
federal level today.
Public agencies and local governments should be prohibited from hiring
In B.C., some universities, local governments, professional bodies such
as the College of Dental Surgeons of B.C. and federal agencies like Via
Rail and Port Metro Vancouver have all retained lobbyists in the past.
If there was an industry award for client development, it would have to
go to Earnscliffe Strategy, who has represented Deloitte since 2013.
The goal: to raise Deloitte's profile and awareness about the services
they bring to government. Who knew it needed raising?
Never let it be said that having a higher profile doesn't come with a
price. For someone.
In 2010, Deloitte billed the B.C. government a little less than $20
million. By 2015, their billings had risen to more than $50 million.
Hope that wasn't a contingency deal.
Dermod Travis is the executive director of IntegrityBC.
© Copyright (c) 2009-2016 The Valley Voice